Bill Achtmeyer joins Matters Graph as first chairman of advisory board
Bill Achtmeyer, the founder of strategy firm Parthenon Group, has joined Matters Graph, a Washington, DC-headquartered buy-side-only commercial due diligence firm, as its inaugural chairman of the advisory board.
Achtmeyer will work with Mark Stein and Jeff Merkle, Matters Graph’s co-founders and senior partners, on the firm’s next stages of growth – including its governance, senior team, published research, and relationships with sponsors.
Matters Graph was founded in 2017 as Graph Strategy USA and has 39 employees listed on LinkedIn. The strategy consultancy focuses exclusively on commercial due diligence for buyers and commercial value creation for the businesses its clients own. Matters Graph works with private equity sponsors, private credit, and corporate development teams.
“Bill and I have become fast friends over the past two years, and he has come to know our firm from the inside,” said Stein. “Chairing our Advisory Board is a different order of commitment, and he was the first and only person we wanted for it.”
Achtmeyer is one of the foremost figures in American management consulting. He joined Bain & Company in 1977 and within 14 years was one of the firm’s 10 senior partners and founder of the M&A practice. In 1991, Achtmeyer founded Parthenon Group, growing the strategy firm to nearly $100 million in revenue before selling it to EY in 2014. He then led EY-Parthenon through 2019, growing EY’s strategy division to $2 billion in revenue and 5,000 consultants.
Since 2021, Achtmeyer has served as chairman and managing partner of Acropolis Advisors, a CEO advisory firm he co-founded with Michael Porter – the co-founder of Monitor Group, which today forms the strategy division of Monitor Deloitte.
“[Mark Stein] and his partner, Jeff Merkle, have built something very special, and it reminds me of when I began the M&A practice at Bain & Company and the private equity practice at The Parthenon Group,” said Achtmeyer. “What distinguishes Mark, Jeff, and their team is their focus on two critical elements in the private equity commercial due diligence world. First, they do only buy-side work. Second, they focus their work on the acquisition target’s customers. They do not rely on expert groups. They do not rubber-stamp the investment thesis of the deal team. They act, as all consultants should, as objective arbiters.”
Private equity is holding the largest backlog of unsold firms in its history, with Bain & Company estimating the figure at 32,000 buyout-backed companies worth $3.8 trillion.
Matters Graph believes a large share of the backlog can be traced to poor diligence, with companies bought at prices that assumed growth and value creation unsupported by rigorous testing. Since the consultancy thinks return on an acquisition is set at purchase, Matters Graph aims to help investors win the exit by winning the acquisition decision – not the bid.
“A deck can’t crack a case that was tested only lightly,” said Stein. “We write the thesis first and then test it rigorously, with extensive investigative primary research coupled with only sound, hard external data, focused on the few questions the return depends on.”
